Sins Only a Feminist Can Commit



Depending on where you stand the views of one room are always different.

What I’ve learned from this week of blogging is that the largest obstacle to any sort of healing or unity is the inability to get past self-interest.  I’m not talking about the obvious kind of self-interest when you’re glossing over your own bum in the passing window, but the self-interest when inventory is done only for your vault; measuring your net losses or gains.  It’s not that simple. 

…Insights and possibilities for social transformation are often trapped by ego-related attitudes and claims regarding the ownership of truth…   Leela Fernandes, Transforming Feminist Practice

Translation: Believing your view of the room is the only legitimate one.
Vanity.  No wonder it’s one of the 7 deadly sins.
Feminist Vanity?  Now we’re REALLY talking destruction.

Even Good Things Leave Scars

I’m married.

This June, Adonis and I will celebrate 3 years of some serious lovin’. He rocks and I adore him.

When we wed, I slipped on a ring that is wavy in cut, original in design. After a while (2 and a half years), I noticed that my skin underneath the band was embedding the ring design. For some reason, it irked me to the bone to have my natural body alter in such a way. So, one night when I drank too much vino, I kissed Adonis in his sleep and pulled off my wedding band to let my skin heal and go back to normal.

That was about 2 months ago and my ring finger is adjusting. When I run my fingers over the imprint, I notice that time and air has breathed life back into the scar.

Interestingly, people notice that my ring is gone and wonder all sorts of wild things. People wonder if we’re in trouble or if this is my new “feminist” thing or if I am contemplating divorce. Such a small piece of my life, a small ring of silver with rubies and diamonds, can go missing and then cause a small flurry. I tell folks, “Nothing’s changed!” My deepening love is still the same as it was before I removed the ring to heal.

I took out “feminist” as a descriptor in my bio description. Something needs to heal there, too. In light of recent observations, identifying as “feminist” causes back of the throat vomit tastings. I’m still me – same writing, same lava. I’m just swimming in uncertainty these days about “feminism,” and hope that time and space will breathe life into my “feminist” scar; this ring that I once proudly wore. The world hasn’t changed much from last week when I was hard core “feminist,” – womyn are still dying and gasping for breath under a brutal global economy. This culture, last time I checked, is still a rape culture. Giving up a descriptor is a brief dusting of my internal shelves of identity. Small impact in the grand picture of life. It’s important to me though and it’s worth writing about.

But, unlike my wedding band, I don’t know if I ‘ll put this one back on in the future.

We’ll see.

Now, before I die I’d like to focus on more important matters.

Ahh, the Irony

Now, don’t get me wrong. Approximately 129 people in my life emailed, linked, or suggested that I visit the boomilicious blog, “Stuff White People Like.” It has been the skyrocketing Grey’s Anatomy of the blogging world, second only to Post Secret. Most, not all, but most of their writing is downright hilarious.

I particularly appreciate their pointing out what white folks love – #92 – Book Deals. And what irony I found today, the day where I needed a good laugh – the day when Brownfemipower ceased her internet presence after years of blogging about media justice, womyn at the border, transformative feminist theory, advocacy for Brown womyn, and safe space – is the same day that I find that the authors of Stuff White People Like has a new book through Random House and Jessica Valenti has a new upcoming book on sexuality. And Post Secret is probably going on Book #5 with Harper Collins sometime next Sunday.

Don’t misread me. Those books are going to be hot tamales and I’ll probably still visit SWPL every now and again with Adonis when we’re brushing our teeth in the morning. And whenever I go to Border’s and see Frank Warren’s latest and greatest, I stop and read the newest secrets bared to the world. A laugh or tear escapes, too.

But, does anyone else see just a smidge of irony here? We need all kinds of voices out there, yes, but what does it say when a voice like Brownfemipower calls it quits while others continue to roll in the wonderful Book Deals that white folks love so much, according to SWPL?

I’m Not So Sure Anymore, Feminism and Reality

I took this picture 48 hours ago.

Tucked away in a corner by the Gulf of Mexico, I ran to the edge of the water to snap this picture and paused in the serenity of the moment.

That was 48 hours ago.

In my offline feminist world, there is no stealing and full integrity.
There are no “feminist” editors spreading manure.
…in my offline life, where I am standing up and not sitting down blogging, I am held accountable in my writing should I ever take from a sister’s work. And, yes, she IS your sister. (Seriously, where are your scruples?) So, why should it be different in our work on the internet?

In my offine feminist world, there are no “comments,” just conversations about how are in this together and how there isn’t all that much time before “we” become “they;” we become the disregarded and discredited old-timers whose words are lost to the new generation of folks who are learning what liberation means to them.

Where have we gone, Feminism? Are we so caught up in ourselves that we’ve forgotten to say Thank You or give even a head nod to someone who worked so fervently and consistently on immigration as a feminist issue when we try and spread the word about womyn at the border?

Have we become so self-righteous and defensive that we call someone “deranged”(nope, I don’t link to hating blogs) because we don’t understand another’s expressive language? Or that we stop and point at a painful e-incident and pass it off as a hee-hee/point-and-look moment?

Are we not better than this; where our sites and blogs and “feminist writing” have become battle grounds? Have we also forgotten that the moments, hours, and years we have spent typing in front of a computer screen are rooftops of privilege that only a fraction of the world can claim as a hobby? Or a job?

When did this collection of movements that we call a “Women’s Movement” become a scheme for publishing, an avenue of money making, or a shortcut to fame in the name of liberation? We need leaders. We don’t need icons. We need truth tellers and thinkers. We don’t need “professional feminists.”

As I am finding the true face of “feminism” for womyn of color and contemplating what it means to me, I am beginning to wonder if I will accomplish more in my offline activism if I abandon this term, this political identity, where I have found the most resistance to my liberation work.

48 hours ago, there was serenity in my lens. When I add feminism, there seems to be cracks all over it.

Feminists, too, Steal

It’s a pretty simple concept.

Stop stealing.

Cite your ideas, words, and the one who gave you the thought.

Stop stealing.

That echo? That echo I’m hearing in the “feminist” blogosphere is getting a bit too loud for me these days. I’ve been hearing it for years.

You know who you are.

It’s a pretty simple concept, you know. We all learned it at some point in our development:

Give credit where credit is due.

That wasn’t your seed, so cite where it came from. Stop spinning it like it’s your own.

Stop stealing.

Update: 4/11/08
Funny how this post is being perceived and linked for various reasons. Understandably, given the timing of the latest train wreck and the exclusive BFP links I used in it, this post is being framed as if I had one incident in mind.

Let’s back up and do some of my favorite work called Clarifying.

BFP was certainly part of my thought process, but this demand for writers/bloggers to “stop stealing” far exceeds the events (disasters) of this week or just BFP herself. This post vomited on the years of hearing echos in the blogosphere with no visible credit or citation to others’ contributions. My links are specific, but my point is wider. I’m not talking about one singular instance that set me off into a knee-jerk reactionary post, I’m speaking about a maddening phenomenon of disregarding BODIES of work . And I’m tired of something that is so deeply problematic being casually normalized by writers and readers of feminism.

Steinhatchee, Florida

I am in Florida.

Honored to be in a ceremony where two womyn joined in love and in commitment celebrated their union, Adonis and I are with friends taking a much needed break from Boston. My two friends who have declared their love to the world asked just a handful of friends to gather in a remote getaway union celebration.

The issue of gay marriage is strongly on my mind as I witness this. More on that later.

I’ve never been to Steinhatchee, Florida, but it’s provided a breath away from the east coast hustle.

I’ll be back full blogging tomorrow.

Until then.

Contigo,
Sudy

"Radical," Feminism, Boston, and WAM: Free Write

This is just a free write about some topics that have been circulating in my head from the weekend. This is my last post about WAM (Women, Action, and the Media Conference).

There are two things I want to blog about right now: the term radical and my WAMmo experience.

First question – Do people understand what ‘radical’ means to individual feminists? Do people see that insignia on blogs that reads, “Radical Women of Color Blog Ring,” and think terror? Do people understand that it’s a natural group dynamic to find comfort in a name while still expressing differing opinions on the actual definition?

1) Radical is derived from the latin word for ROOT. Getting to the bottom of things, the truth of the matter. Dilly dallying with the petals and surface is not my feminism. Mine is rooted in the rich soil, the dirt that gives life. I’m radical because

2) I’m anti-excessive consumerism. READ: I’m not anti-money. I’m anti-excessive. Adonis and I want to have little feminists running around someday and they need a roof. They’ll need food. We have a car and I buy tofu and meat. But, I build a strong wall around consumption and believe that excessive consumption, selling, buying, and money/power-driven economics is the darkest shadow of the proverbial “Women’s Movement,” that celebrates icons instead communities, marketing instead of distribution, and trends instead of justice.

3) I’m radical because I believe in the equality of womyn of color. I believe that stairs are more than stairs when there are no elevators for womyn who cannot climb them. I believe that jokingly threatening EXECUTION to a crowd of women that has womyn of color in it in the name of safe space and confidentiality is wrong and hurtful. I am radical because while I may not agree with others, I will stand by their anger and support their voices. I’m radical because equality means more than just additional sidebar links. I’m radical because I detest stealing ideas and not citing the author and blogger from where you found the information. I’m radical because I have found “normalcy” to equate complacency. I am not a feminist who will sit in silence while Brown and Black and Yellow and Red womyn become displaced and pretend that pickets and online petitions are enough. It is not enough.

Radical is not negative, folks. There seems to be a misunderstanding that when womyn of color are angry, it’s all negative. From the WOC I am in community with, there is anger. Lots of it. It’s in our blood from a life line of violence, rape, and racism. I think people hear what they want to hear and what they want to hear is the anger, it makes WOC easier to dismiss. But, the creative energy, the laughter and light is ten fold the anger. I’m angry, sure, but I’m much more than the anger and I believe in more positivity than I do in bitterness.

How does that relate to WAM?

Veronica talked about her good and bad experience of WAM and I agree with several of her points. I don’t speak for anyone else, not even those who I housed when I say that WAM, like so many other conferences I have attended (e.g. NWSA) have much work to do with regard to racial divides. WAM is the brainchild of the Center for New Words, a non-profit org here in Cambridge that prioritizes, yes prioritizes, marginalized voices. The programs that I have attended have been provocative and stirring. Their rich history is a celebration of perseverance and will. Why should I not believe that WAM would be the same?

Thursday 9pm
I am giggling. A lot. I’m so excited for everything to unfold. I throw myself on a hotel bed and joke, “There better not be any pro-Hillary pundits telling me how to vote. I’m going to vomit.”
Hee Hee Hee – that’s not gonna happen, Sudy.

We are eating indian food and are laughing over everything and nothing. Folks are staring because we are loudly laughing. They are glancing over their shoulders and their backs feel like walls. We tip well and leave.

We enter a book store in Harvard Square. “Do you have Andrea Smith’s Conquest?”
No.

Thursday 10:37pm
We’re on the train, giggling about anything and everything. A tall man closes in and leans toward us, “You girls look like you’re having a good time. Do you want to hear some jokes?”
BA and Nadia are sitting across from me. I look at Wifey. She can already sense trouble.

Even though my nose still stings from any contact with fabric because of my piercing, I bury my face in Wifey’s armpit as this man shoots out disgusting racially charged and sexist jokes. I cover my face with my hands. Peaking briefly across the way, Nadia and BA have done the same. Nicole, a friend, utters, “I think that’s enough of the jokes, Sir.” He tries one more. Dead silence. He leaves us alone.

Friday 11am
One of the most contentious issues with any feminist conference is the politics of attendance. The can-attend and can’t-attend is something I take seriously. (You know, I’m radical like that.) For the can’t-attends, LIVE BLOGGING is a great tool to channel the wisdom and information to those who could not afford the conference, take time off of work, be away from families, or find adequate means to spend a weekend in Boston. What is shared is passed on to readers. It’s a tool commonly called LIVE BLOGGING, I’m old school and call it, SHARING.

As I took pictures and wrote down quotes and springing ideas, out of nowhere it was stressed that no blogging, publicizing, or quoting was allowed. Got it, says me, the lady with the Nikon SLR. Laugh, laugh – we’ll execute you. Got it, says me, the lady with the Nikon. No, really, we’ll execute you if you threaten this safe space of confidentiality. Got it, says me, the lady with the Nikon. Execute you. Execute. Execute.

This is a journalists’ conference. This is, “Where women’s words matter.” Oh, it matters alright.

Ok.

But, if I say anything, I am breaking confidentiality. Well, I’m not quoting, posting photos, or doing anything less than writing my experience. Hey, I’m just a radical Nikon lady trying to get out the goods others. I guess voicing threatens other’s safe space. It was not a safe space for me though. “Execute?” Ooops, that was a quote.

Friday 8pm
Opening keynote…”Bitch is the new black.”
“Someday we’ll have own female Don Imus.”
Swhaaaaaaa??
Did Saturday Night Live just squeak its way into this conference? Is that a Hill endorsement?
Did you just suggest that we need a female racist to utter spiteful comments into the radio waves so we’re equal?

This is liberation?

Friday 10pm
I’m running around, trying to get folks settled, fed, and happy. BFP needs a Shamrock shake and some hot womyn tries to pick her up while she’s walking out of McDs. I’m waiting in the car. Flashers are on, illegal parking. Stressssssss. No time to process what just happened today. Yet.

Saturday 12:30am
Security asks us to be quiet. It’s the Marriot, not a libary! We don’t want to get kicked out. We shush eat other’s voices for the next hour and a half while we gently plan our session. We muffle our laughter with pillows.
BA asks, “Is there somewhere in Boston where we can just laugh and be ourselves?”

Saturday 10:56am
I am driving wild. But I live here in Boston and that’s why I fit in. The panel on Immigration is superb but I am wondering why people think that getting coverage on Bill O’Reilly’s show is worth talking about. Why are we even talking about people like Don Imus and Bill O’Reilly? For a few moments, I am having an out of body experience.

Saturday 11:28am
BFP is soaring and I watch her wings with love.

Saturday 12:30pm
I am carrying my sandwich and cannot wait to devour it while we have or Radical Womyn of Color Blogger’s Caucus.

Saturday 12:54pm
Lex and I discover our room is double booked with a film screening. We walk to information, Our room is double booked.

“That’s not possible.”

My sandwich feels like it weighs 10lbs and my WAM bag is getting sweaty from my wet hands.
Blood sugar is dropping. I need sustenance. Now.

Our room is double booked.

“Did you check the program?”

I am having another out of body experience. Blooood sugarrrr drrropppinngg. Thank God for Lex.

Saturday 1:03pm
“There’s a room now.”

Saturday 1:20pm
We talk goods. We talk struggles.

Saturday 2:oopm
Our glorious session begins. A room full of womyn express their wishes for the world. A womyn brings 6 generations of Black womyn’s struggles into the room. My heart is overflowing with joy. I keep thinking, “THIS is who we are.” If only everyone else could see what we can do when we have the space, time, and freedom to create and Speak ourselves into existence. Jill and Octo make my heart smile. The energy fills me. The world, I feel, is so full of goodness and beauty.

Saturday 4pm.
An embrace I still feel.

Saturday 5pm
I am appointed driver of a huge minivan and cram it full of womyn of color feminists. It feels like family. This is my family. I drive like a wild womyn and need to wash my mouth out with soap for what I said to an unstable cyclist on Tremont and Boylston Street. We retire to my pad to rest up for tonight.

Saturday 7pm
Um, the Queer WOC and Allies reception is the same time as the WAM party. I tell Adonis, “I wanna dance tonight.” The WAM party’s got a DJ, but the other party’s got my name on it. He seems perplexed at the dilemma. Is it a misprint, he asks. I wonder if anyone notices this. Uh yeah, everyone brings it up. Is this social segregation?

The Queer/WOC/Allies party rocks hard and it’s a beautiful space full of laughter and comfort. BFP and I air-guitar during Pour Some Sugar on Me. Passerby-ers of The Tavern gawk at a dark room full of womyn dancing, rubbing, kissing, laughing, and drinking. Nothing to see here, just us, being…us.

I could count the allies I met on one hand.

Sunday 1am
BFP and I drive back while others go to IHop.

Sunday 4am
Nadia calls. Can you let us in?

Sunday 11am
I attend mass because I’m a radical Catholic like that. I pray for strength, peace, unity for feminists. I ask G*d for all kinds of things and hope She didn’t hear what I said to that cyclist.

Sunday 1:30
Black Seed Cafe charges your first born child for a pastrami sandwich. We eat. Wifey and BA are leaving soon. My thoughts are beginning to turn sad as their departures begin.

Sunday 2:17pm
Wifey’s purse is gone. The blue canvas, “Obama is My Homeboy” purse that I coveted is gone. How is that possible, I wonder, when I sat across from her the entire time? Her phone, iPod, wallet, Greyhound ticket, ID, LIFE is in there.

Sunday 2:30pm
Call the police for a report. Call credit cards to cancel. We are instructed to go to one of the police’s kiosks down the block to write a report. We arrive. No one is there. We call again.
Please hold. Please hold. Please hold. Please hold.

An officer arrives at the kiosk contradicts the officer on the phone. “You can’t make a report here.”

Please hold. Please hold. Please hold. Please hold.

“Take the train to Haymarket stop. Look up and there’s the police station. That’s where you make the report.”

Wifey’s on the phone with Wachovia Bank who are giving her a difficult time. Why won’t anyone help her?

Two officers in a car. Lex asks, “Please, can you give her a ride to the station? We’re from out of town, she needs to catch a bus. She has no ID. “

“No. You need to ask someone else. We don’t work with the Boston Police. We’re a different department.”

Please, someone. Help us. We’re walking around this city with luggage, long faces, and 2 friends who need to leave.

The officers pull away from us in their car, literally.

I yell, “Her purse was stolen and no one will help us. Can anyone, someone please help us?”

Stares.

Of course stares. A bunch of womyn, a lot of color, and luggage. A yell. Must mean trouble.

We get on the train. Haymarket. We go to the info desk, “Where is the police station?”

“Oh, you go up the street. It’s up there, if it’s still there.”

‘Scuse me?

“It may have moved.”

The police station may have moved? Thanks.

We march onward. The air is cold and the city is colder. My friends ask me if the city is always like this and I reflect. It never has been that way to me. How are all of these things happening? Is it because of who I am standing with? A bunch of womyn of color who need help and have a voice? Maybe. Maybe not. What I do know is that frustration is mounting and I am exhausted.

The police station is worse.

“What’s the address of the place it was stolen?”

Wifey is being too kind, she freaking calls 411 on someone else’s phone to get the address for the person taking her report. Do they know what a phone book is?

“Do you have a picture ID?”

BA looks like she will assassinate anyone that breathes. Lex, BFP, Nadia and I are incredulous. She JUST spent the last 15 minutes explaining how EVERYTHING was stolen. Nadia goes to smoke.

I contemplate beginning to smoke.

Sunday 4:28pm
BA and Wifey head toward Greyhound. The rest retire to my apartment.

Sunday 8pm
Lex’s plane is supposed to depart from Logan aiport.

Sunday 8:32pm
Lex is asked to get off the plane because it is too heavy. Lex weighs approximately 97lbs and is bumped to help the plane get its butt off the ground.
She heads back to my place.

Sunday 9pm
We all eat and celebrate the weekend. My eyes begin to droop at midnight.

Monday 1:15am
We hug good night.

Monday 4:30am
Bfp and Lex get to airport. The planes are at even weight apparently.

Monday 7:00am
I drive Nadia to the airport.

Monday 10am
Process with Adonis, my sister, and Self begin.

What do I need to say about my WAM experience? It had its moments. It has its clouds.
I know how much work goes into conferences and how much of one’s Self goes into planning, work, and detail. I respect that and all the hours that went into it. But there were things that transpired there that had nothing to do with the conference details, but about the general “Women’s Movement” atmosphere. A much larger issue than one conference exists. I don’t believe that everything that happened this weekend is an indication of a divide, but I do think that portions of the conference speak to much larger problems that exist between feminists.

I also don’t believe that simply putting a womyn’s face where a man’s face once was is going to solve our problems. Mainstream media will never hear the voice of Real Womyn and by Real Womyn I am talking about womyn of color, incarcerated womyn, migrant womyn, womyn at the border, womyn gripped in violence, rape, and war. Mainstream media does not cover these stories and when it does it narrows the experience and distorts the truth to make is sensationalized and flashy. Feminists who believe in telling true Stories of womyn will struggle in media “reform.” For those want Justice, get to the Allied Media Conference.

What I don’t want to do is feed the binary feel of feminism – across race or religion or citizenship – or anything. There is a place for honesty and anger – always. But I also feel that there is a need for critical analysis of why division exists, what is gained AND lost when separation occurs in feminism. While I remain critical of mainstream feminism and its flaws, that critical analysis is not absent from the communities that I identify. What can I, a womyn of color, do to bridge this divide?

The highs and positivity are what I want to focus on. Most of the highs were provided by the company I kept and the womyn and allies in our session. I can’t say enough about Jess Hoffman and how excited I am to work with her on make/shift. There’s not enough vocabulary to express what transpired in our session with all those other womyn. The space provided where womyn can safely create, remember, and piece their vision together is the face of feminism to me.

That is what radical means to me.